Sheetly vs Sheet Music Scanner: Hear the Page, or Practise It?
Choosing between Sheetly and Sheet Music Scanner? In this guide, we compare a cheap, long-established app that plays a photographed page with an app built around what you do with the page afterwards, and help you pick the one you need.
Sheet Music Scanner is one of the original scan-and-play apps. You photograph a page, and it plays it back on any of more than 30 instruments. It is cheap, it has been around for years, and it can even save the result as an audio file. If you just want to know how a piece goes, it does that job well.
Sheetly starts in the same place: photograph a page or open a PDF, and press play. The difference is what comes next. Sheetly is built around practising the page: looping the bar you keep getting wrong, recording yourself, and asking a coach that has read the notes.
These two are closer than most pairs we compare. Below, we look at them side by side, starting with where Sheet Music Scanner is the better buy.
- Sheet Music Scanner is a cheap, long-established app that photographs a page, plays it on 30+ instruments at 50–330 bpm, and exports MIDI, MusicXML, audio and PDF.
- Sheetly photographs a page, plays it, loops a bar, records your take, exports PDF, MIDI and MusicXML with Forte, and includes a coach that has read the notes of the page.
- Sheetly publishes its accuracy benchmark: 97.37% strict F1 on clean scores and 97.34% on phone photographs of a 31-piece suite. Sheet Music Scanner has not been measured in that test.
A note on who wrote this: we make Sheetly. Every claim about another product comes from that product’s own materials, and we say plainly where it is better. We publish numbers only where we have measured something, and we have not measured Sheet Music Scanner.
Where Sheet Music Scanner is the better choice
Both apps start from a photograph or a PDF and hand you a play button. Sheet Music Scanner stops at “hear”, and it does that cheaply and well.
It has a 4.5 App Store rating from 6.4K ratings, a one-off in-app purchase, more than 30 playback instruments, a tempo range of 50–330 bpm, and audio export in M4A, AAC, MP3 and WAV. Sheetly has none of those audio formats, and it costs more.
It has been around a long time
Sheet Music Scanner, originally by David Zemsky and now published by App Sub 1 LLC, is one of the original scan-and-play apps. A 4.5 rating across 6.4K ratings is a large group of people who got what they paid for, and we are a newer product.
It is cheap
It is free to download, with a single one-off in-app purchase. If your whole need is “play this page so I know how it goes”, that is very hard to argue with, and we will not try.
Thirty-plus instruments and transposing pitch
Sheet Music Scanner plays back on more than 30 instruments and handles transposing instruments, so a clarinet or horn part sounds at the right pitch for that instrument. Sheetly offers piano, organ, violin, flute, trumpet and the other instruments on its list, plus a drum kit. Our list is shorter.
Audio export
Sheet Music Scanner exports M4A, AAC, MP3 and WAV alongside MIDI, MusicXML and PDF. Sheetly exports PDF, MIDI and MusicXML, but not audio files. If you want a backing track as an audio file for a student or a choir, that is a real difference in its favour.
Android
Sheet Music Scanner has an Android “Pro” version. Sheetly is on iPhone and iPad only.
Where Sheetly is the better choice
Sheetly publishes its accuracy benchmark, loops a single bar or passage, records your own take against the score, has a coach that has read the notes of the page, and exports MusicXML with Forte. Sheet Music Scanner does not document the loop, the recording or a coach.
The accuracy is published
Sheetly publishes its benchmark with the method, the dated run and the public test set. It scores 97.37% strict F1 on clean scores and 97.34% on phone photographs of a 31-piece suite. On 60 systems cut from real scanned pages in the public OLiMPiC set it scores 92.3% mean and 99.3% median. Audiveris 5.11.0 scores 88% and 50% on the 31-piece suite, and 58% mean and 64% median on OLiMPiC.
Strict F1 counts a note only when its pitch, onset and duration are all correct. We have not run the closed commercial apps through the same test, so we publish no number for them. Here is the method.
Sheet Music Scanner’s own listing is candid about its limits. Codas, percussion notation, dynamics, double sharps and flats, and grace notes are listed as unsupported, and earlier versions also listed repeat signs and tuplets. We mention that neutrally. Every recogniser has limits, and Sheetly reads printed notation only, not handwriting or tab.
Loop one bar
Photograph it, hear it, understand it, practise it. The practising part is a loop: pick the bar or passage that keeps falling apart and let it repeat, at a tempo you can manage, while you work on it.

Sheet Music Scanner lets you tap a measure to play from anywhere, which is a quick way back to a passage, but we could not find a repeating loop described. Here is how looping works in Sheetly.
Record your take
Sheetly records your own playing against the score so you can hear the two side by side. It does not grade you. We could not find recording documented in Sheet Music Scanner’s materials.
The coach
Sheetly is the only iPhone and iPad app we know of where the AI coach has read the actual notes of the page you photographed, so a question about bar 12 gets an answer about your bar 12. Ask what a marking means, how a rhythm subdivides, what fingering to try, or what to drill tonight.
For example, ask “bar 12 keeps falling apart, what am I doing wrong?” and it might tell you that bar 12 is where the left hand crosses over, and suggest a 2–1–3 fingering with the wrist moving right through the bar. Ask what to drill tonight and it might say bars 12 to 15, hands separately, at 60. The coach reads the page; it does not listen to you play.
Sheet Music Scanner has no coach. It hands you the playback and stops.
PDF, MIDI and MusicXML export
Sheetly exports PDF, MIDI and MusicXML with Forte, so the page can go into MuseScore, Dorico or Sibelius. Sheet Music Scanner also exports MusicXML, plus audio. The difference is not the format but what the app lets you do before you export.
Sheet Music Scanner and Sheetly, feature by feature
This table comes from each app’s own materials. Apps change, so check the current version before you buy.
| After the scan, can you… | Sheetly | Sheet Music Scanner |
|---|---|---|
| Hear it played back | Yes | Yes |
| Change the tempo | Yes, any tempo | Yes, 50–330 bpm |
| Play from any measure | Yes | Yes, tap the measure |
| Loop one difficult bar | Yes | Not documented |
| Record your own take against it | Yes | Not documented |
| Ask questions about your score | Yes | No |
| Playback instruments | Piano, organ, strings, winds, brass and more | 30+, with transposing pitch |
| Export MusicXML / MIDI / PDF | Yes, with Forte | Yes |
| Export audio (M4A, MP3, WAV) | No | Yes |
| Published accuracy benchmark | Yes | Not documented |
| Documented notation limits | Printed only; no handwriting, tab or shape notes | No codas, percussion, dynamics, double sharps/flats, grace notes |
| How you pay | Forte subscription | Free download, one-off in-app purchase |
| Runs on | iPhone, iPad | iOS, Android (Pro) |
The payment row and the audio row are two things Sheet Music Scanner does better than we do. If a cheap one-off purchase and an MP3 out are what you need, the rest of the table does not matter much.
Which one should you choose?
Get Sheet Music Scanner for the cheapest way to hear a page played on an instrument of your choice, perhaps saved as audio. Get Sheetly to practise and understand the page: loop the hard bar, record your take, ask the coach what is written, and export MusicXML with Forte, with a published accuracy number behind the scan.
- You just want to know how the piece goes. Sheet Music Scanner. It is cheap and it has done this for years.
- You need a backing track as an MP3 or WAV. Sheet Music Scanner.
- You play a transposing instrument and want it to sound right. Sheet Music Scanner documents transposing pitch; we do not claim it.
- You keep getting one bar wrong. Sheetly. Loop it, slow it down, ask about it.
- You want to hear your own playing against the score. Sheetly.
- You want to know how accurate the scan is before you trust it. Sheetly, because the number is published with the method.
Questions
Is Sheetly free?
No. Sheetly runs on iPhone and iPad as a Forte subscription, which includes scanning, the coach and PDF, MIDI and MusicXML export.
Can Sheetly export audio files like Sheet Music Scanner?
No. Sheetly exports PDF, MIDI and MusicXML, not audio. Sheet Music Scanner exports M4A, AAC, MP3 and WAV as well.
Does Sheet Music Scanner read dynamics and grace notes?
Its own listing names codas, percussion notation, dynamics, double sharps and flats, and grace notes as unsupported. Sheetly reads printed notation, but not handwriting, tab or shape notes.