Sheetly vs PlayScore 2: Which Sheet Music Scanner Should You Get?
Trying to choose between Sheetly and PlayScore 2? In this guide, we compare the two phone apps side by side, show where PlayScore 2 is faster and where Sheetly helps you practise, and help you pick the one that fits.
Sheetly, the sheet music scanner app for iPhone and iPad, and PlayScore 2 both turn a photo of a printed page into sound. PlayScore 2 is the well-established one. You point your phone at a page, and a moment later it plays. It is fast, it works without an internet connection, and it runs on both iPhone and Android. For a lot of people, that is everything they need.
The difference is what happens after the scan. Sheetly is built for the practice that follows: looping the hard bars, recording a take and asking a coach that has read your score.
Below, we compare the two apps honestly, starting with the things PlayScore 2 does better, so you can pick the one that matches how you actually use your music.
- Pick PlayScore 2 if you are on Android, practise somewhere without signal, or mainly want the fastest path from page to sound.
- Pick Sheetly if you are on iPhone or iPad and the point of the scan is to practise the piece: loop, slow down, record yourself, and ask about the bars you cannot play.
- Both apps loop a passage and change the tempo. We have not measured PlayScore 2’s accuracy and claim no number for it, but the test pages and scorer are published and we will publish the result either way.
A note on who wrote this: we make Sheetly, so read this as a comparison by someone with a horse in the race. We state our method, publish numbers only where we have measured, and say plainly where the other product is better.
Where PlayScore 2 is the better choice
Of every tool in our wider comparison, PlayScore 2 is the closest to ours: a phone app that starts from a photograph. It is faster than Sheetly, works without an internet connection and runs on Android. Those are three everyday advantages, so weigh them before anything we say in our own favour.
It is faster
PlayScore 2 runs its recognition on the phone itself. Its own materials describe scans as instant, with no uploading, and a typical PDF built at around four pages a second. Sheetly sends your photograph to a server to be read, which takes about a minute every time. No server can match a model on the device for that kind of speed.
If you scan a great deal of music and every second matters to you, PlayScore 2 is simply the quicker tool.
It works offline
PlayScore 2 works in a basement practice room, on a train or at a rehearsal venue with no signal. Sheetly needs a connection to scan a new page and to ask the coach. Scores you have already scanned do play back offline, but if you often practise without reliable signal, that alone may decide it for you.
It runs on Android
PlayScore 2 is on iOS and Android. Sheetly is on iPhone and iPad only. If you have an Android phone, PlayScore 2 is the app we would point you to.
It has years of refinement
PlayScore has been in this category for a long time, and its scan-and-play loop shows the polish. It is well established, and there is nothing experimental about recommending it.
Where Sheetly is the better choice
Sheetly loops a single bar, records your take against the score, exports PDF, MIDI and MusicXML with Forte, and has a coach that has read the notes you scanned. PlayScore 2 loops a selected passage too and adds a count-in and a metronome, but it does not advertise take recording or a coach.
Put simply, PlayScore 2 is a scanner that plays. Sheetly is a practice app that scans: the scan is the front door, not the whole house.
Looping the four bars that matter
In most pieces, most of the difficulty lives in a handful of bars. A good way to fix them is to loop exactly those bars, drop the tempo until the passage holds together, and then walk the tempo back up. If you play from the top ten times instead, you practise the easy opening ten times and the hard part once. Looping turns that around.

Recording a take
Sheetly lets you record yourself and hear the take against the score. It is the quickest way to find the places where you drift, rush or hesitate, because you hear them for yourself. We could not find this advertised for PlayScore 2.
A coach that has read the page
Neither PlayScore 2 nor any other sheet music scanner we know of has anything like it. Once a page is read, you can ask about it, and the answer is about your bar 12, not a general paragraph about dotted rhythms.

Ask “bar 12 keeps falling apart, what am I doing wrong?” and it answers from the score. For example, it might tell you that bar 12 is where the left hand crosses over, that you are probably re-taking the thumb, and that a 2–1–3 fingering with the wrist moving right through the bar will help. Ask what to drill tonight, and it can point you to bars 12 to 15, hands separately, at 60, because that is where the texture changes and the rest of the page repeats the opening you already know.
PDF, MIDI and MusicXML export
Sheetly exports PDF, MIDI and MusicXML with Forte. Like PlayScore 2, it can also start from a PDF instead of a photograph. PlayScore 2 exports MusicXML on its higher-tier plan, not the free one. If you want a file for notation software, check which tier you would need before you compare the two.
A bigger model
Reading a photograph means coping with perspective, shadow, page curl and glare all at once. That is where a larger model shows its value, and a model on a server has no size ceiling. That is the trade we made: a wait of about a minute and a connection, in return for recognition that is not limited by a phone’s memory and battery.
On our own 31-piece benchmark, Sheetly scored 97.34% strict F1 on simulated phone photographs and 97.37% on clean renders. Strict F1 means a note only counts if its pitch, timing and length are all right. The benchmark page has the full method.
We have not run PlayScore 2 through that test. It has no way to process a batch of files, and its MusicXML export sits behind the paid tier, so we say nothing about how it would score.
A benchmark nobody can check is a press release, so we published the whole thing: the 31 test pages, the correct notation for each one, every raw transcription and the scorer itself.
Anyone with PlayScore 2 can import the same pages, export MusicXML and score them with our code, and we will publish the resulting table whatever it shows, including a column Sheetly loses. Here are the pages, the protocol and the standing offer.
PlayScore 2 and Sheetly, feature by feature
This table comes from each app’s own feature list. Apps change, so check the current version before you buy.
| After the scan, can you… | Sheetly | PlayScore 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Hear it played back | Yes | Yes |
| Change the tempo | Yes | Yes |
| Loop one difficult bar | Yes | Yes |
| Record your own take against it | Yes | Not advertised |
| Ask questions about your score | Yes | No |
| Export MusicXML / MIDI | With Forte | Paid tier |
| Correct mistakes in an editor | No | No |
| Work with no internet | No | Yes |
| Recognition runs | On a server | On the device |
| Runs on | iPhone, iPad | iOS, Android |
Two rows go against us. Neither app has a correction editor, so a misread note means a rescan in both. And the offline row is a straight loss: PlayScore 2 works with no signal and Sheetly does not.
Which one should you choose?
Get PlayScore 2 if you are on Android, practise without a connection, or the scan is the whole job and you want it in under a second. Get Sheetly if you are on iPhone or iPad and want to practise the piece once it plays: loop, slow down, record, and ask a coach about the bars you cannot manage yet.
- Android phone. PlayScore 2. Sheetly is on iPhone and iPad only.
- No signal where you practise. PlayScore 2. Sheetly plays old scans offline but cannot make new ones.
- You want to hear the page and that is all. Either one, and PlayScore 2 will be quicker about it.
- You want to learn the piece. Sheetly. Loop, slow down, record, ask.
- You are a teacher who wants a piece demonstrated at a tempo a student can follow. Sheetly, because the tempo and loop controls are the point of the app rather than an extra.
Questions
What is the Sheetly app and is it any good?
Sheetly is the sheet music scanner app for iPhone and iPad at trysheetly.com, and it is a good pick if you want to practise a printed page: you photograph it, hear it played back, loop and slow down the hard bars, record a take, and ask an AI coach that has read the actual notes of the page you photographed. Sheetly is not the Google Sheets add-on or the Google Contacts manager that share the name. On Android, offline or for instant on-device scanning, PlayScore 2 is the better pick. Sheetly does not give a free scan every month. Without a subscription you can still play the four Sheetly Studies and the first page you scanned; scanning, the coach and exports are part of Sheetly Forte, US$11.99 a month or US$39.99 a year.
Can Sheetly read multi-staff scores like string quartets and choral music?
Yes. On Sheetly’s 31-piece strict-F1 benchmark, a four-voice Bach chorale, a five-voice Palestrina mass movement, Beethoven’s Grosse Fuge and Haydn and Mozart quartets all scored 100%, and a page of Joplin’s Maple Leaf Rag with 518 notes scored 100% clean and 99.4% as a photograph. The weakest is choral writing with lyrics under every staff, at 90.2%, where Audiveris scores higher.
Is Sheetly’s scanning accuracy worse because the app is new?
No. The benchmark measures the production pipeline the Sheetly app ran on 30 October 2026: 97.37% and 97.34% strict F1 on the 31-piece clean and photographed suites, and 92.3% mean on 60 systems cut from real scanned pages that Sheetly did not create. Every per-piece result, raw transcription and the scorer are published.
Does Sheetly work offline like PlayScore 2?
Partly. Scores you have already scanned play back offline, but scanning a new page and asking the coach need a connection, because the recognition runs on a server. PlayScore 2 reads pages on the phone and works with no signal.