Sheetly vs Halbestunde: Two Scan-and-Play Apps Compared

Deciding between Sheetly and Halbestunde? In this guide, we compare the two apps that photograph a page and play it, look at what their accuracy numbers really mean, and help you choose the one that fits how you practise.

Hands in a grey sweater playing an upright piano with the front panel open, showing the hammers

Sheetly, the sheet music scanner app for iPhone and iPad, and Halbestunde both photograph a printed page and play it back. Halbestunde is the well-established one. It runs on iPhone, Android and the web, it can transpose a piece into another key, and it comes with a gallery of songs to play before you scan anything.

In Sheetly, you can also import a PDF instead of photographing the page. Once the page plays, the two apps grow in different directions. Halbestunde grows outwards, to more platforms, instruments, songs and keys. Sheetly grows inwards, towards the practice that happens once the page plays, with a coach that has read your notes.

Below, we go through where each app comes out ahead, including where Halbestunde is the better choice, and we explain why the two apps’ accuracy numbers cannot be compared directly.

  • Sheetly is better for an iPhone or iPad player who wants to photograph a page, hear it, loop the hard bars, record a take and ask a coach that has read the notes.
  • Halbestunde is better on Android or the web, for transposition, a built-in song gallery or a lifetime purchase, and it is the more mature product with the larger user base.
  • Sheetly publishes its benchmark with the method, the dated run, the public test set and the raw files, so a stranger can recompute it in twenty-five seconds. Halbestunde’s site states 99% scanning accuracy, and we could not find a method, dataset or definition behind it.

A note on who wrote this: we make Sheetly. Every claim about another product comes from that product’s own materials, and we say plainly where it is better. Where we have measured something we show the method; where we have not, we publish no number.

Where Halbestunde is the better choice

Halbestunde is the better pick if you need Android or a browser, transposition, a lifetime purchase or a song gallery. It is also the more established app, with a 4.3 rating from about 1.4K US reviews.

Of the phone scanners in our wider comparison, Halbestunde is the one most people put next to Sheetly. Here is where it comes out ahead.

Android and the web

Halbestunde runs on iOS, on Android and as a web app at app.halbestunde.com. Sheetly is on iPhone and iPad only. If you have an Android phone, or you want a scanned score open on a laptop, Halbestunde is the one of the two that runs there, and we would point you to it.

Transposition

Halbestunde’s own materials list transposing to another key, alongside 24 instrument and voice options. So a singer who needs a song a tone lower, or a clarinettist reading a piano part, can get it there. Transposition is not a headline feature of Sheetly. If changing key is part of your weekly routine, weigh that heavily.

A song gallery and a virtual piano

Halbestunde comes with a gallery of hundreds of songs and a virtual piano, so there is something to play before you photograph anything. Sheetly starts from your own printed music. With no page in front of you, there is less to do in Sheetly.

A lifetime option and a mature product

Both apps charge through in-app purchases. Halbestunde offers monthly and yearly plans and also a one-off Lifetime purchase. Sheetly is a Forte subscription with no one-off purchase, and many players prefer to pay once.

Sheetly does not give a free scan every month. Without a subscription you can still play the four Sheetly Studies and the first page you scanned; scanning, PDF import, the coach, recording and exports are part of Sheetly Forte, the subscription that used to be called Sheetly Pro.

Halbestunde has also been in the category longer. It has a larger user base, it recognises lyrics and symbols, and it documents a flow for scanning several pages (“tap Next and add pages”). None of that is experimental.

Where Sheetly is the better choice

Sheetly publishes a benchmark you can reproduce instead of a headline number. It has a coach that has read the notes of your page, it loops a bar, it records your take and, with Forte, it exports PDF, MIDI and MusicXML. Photograph it, hear it, understand it, practise it.

An accuracy number you can check

Sheetly publishes its benchmark with the method, the dated run and the public test set. It scores 97.37% strict F1 on clean scores and 97.34% on phone photographs of a 31-piece suite. On 60 systems cut from real scanned pages in the public OLiMPiC set it scores 92.3% mean and 99.3% median. Audiveris 5.11.0, the best free scanner, scores 88% and 50% on the 31-piece suite, and 58% mean and 64% median on OLiMPiC.

Sheetly’s figures are the current ones, from the 30 October 2026 run. The 96% and 95% that some older summaries quote come from the August 2026 run, and the benchmark changelog records every run.

Strict F1 counts a note only when its pitch, onset and duration are all correct. We have not run the closed commercial apps through the same test, so we publish no number for them. The point is not that our number is big. The point is that the benchmark page shows what it means and what it was measured on.

SheetlyAudiveris, the best free scanner
97%
88%
Clean scans
97%
50%
Phone photos
92%
58%
Real scans
Strict scoring on identical pages, October 2026. A note counts only if pitch, timing and length are right. Inputs, raw transcriptions and the scorer are published, so one command reproduces this chart. The benchmark, and how to check it

A coach that has read the page

Sheetly is the only iPhone and iPad app we know of where the AI coach has read the actual notes of the page you photographed, so a question about bar 12 gets an answer about your bar 12. We could not find any question-answering about the score in Halbestunde’s materials.

Ask Sheetly answering how to play the first notes of Ode to Joy, with trombone slide positions for bars 1 to 4 of a scanned part
The coach answers from the scanned page: slide positions for bars 1 to 4.

The coach does not listen to you play. It answers by bar number about fingering, rhythm, what a marking means and what to drill. Ask “bar 12 keeps falling apart, what am I doing wrong?” and it answers from the score: for example, that bar 12 is where the left hand crosses over, so try a 2–1–3 fingering and keep the wrist moving through the bar instead of resetting on the downbeat. Ask what to drill tonight and it might suggest bars 12 to 15, hands separately, at 60, because that is where the texture changes.

Loop, slow down, record

Both apps loop and both record. Halbestunde lists loop sections, tempo control and recording yourself as audio. Sheetly loops a single bar or any passage at any tempo, on piano, organ, flute, trumpet and other instruments, and records your own take against the score.

So we are not claiming a feature Halbestunde lacks, only a tighter circle. In Sheetly the loop, the take and the coach all sit on the same score, so the bar you cannot play is the bar you loop, record and ask about.

Sheetly's player in landscape, with loop, zoom, restart, play, a 90 BPM tempo control, instrument choice and record
Loop the bar, drop the tempo, record the take.

PDF, MIDI and MusicXML export

With Forte, Sheetly exports all three formats (PDF, MIDI and MusicXML), and you can start from a PDF instead of a photograph. Halbestunde lists the same three formats, but we could not find which of its plans include export, so check the plan you would be on before you compare the two.

What does Halbestunde’s 99% accuracy mean?

Halbestunde’s site headline is “Scan and Play Any Sheet Music in Seconds. 99% Scanning Accuracy.” We are not saying that number is false. But we could not find what it counts, what it was measured on, or when. Without those, a percentage cannot be compared with anything, including ours.

Accuracy in music recognition depends on the definition. If you count symbols found, a page with every notehead in place but the wrong durations can score in the high nineties. If you count notes with pitch, onset and duration all correct, which is our strict F1, the same page scores far lower.

The input matters just as much. Clean PDFs push the number up, and phone photographs with shadow and page curl bring it down. Halbestunde’s own photo tips ask for even light, no shadows, portrait orientation and a camera angle “as close to zero as possible”. That is sensible advice, and a hint that the input makes a big difference.

So the fair comparison is a number with a published method against a number without one. If Halbestunde publishes its test set and definition, we would be glad to run both tools on the same pages and put the result on the benchmark page. Until then, we publish no number for Halbestunde and draw no conclusion about it.

Halbestunde and Sheetly, feature by feature

This table comes from each app’s own feature list. Apps change, so check the current version before you buy.

Compiled from each product’s own published feature list, August 2026. “Not advertised” means we could not find the feature documented, not that it is definitely absent.
After the scan, can you… SheetlyHalbestunde
Hear it played back YesYes
Change the tempo YesYes
Loop one difficult bar YesYes, loop sections
Record your own take against it YesYes, audio
Ask questions about your score YesNot advertised
Transpose to another key Not a headline featureYes
Export MusicXML / MIDI / PDF Yes, with ForteYes
Built-in song gallery NoHundreds of songs
Published accuracy method Yes, with public test setNot found
Correct mistakes in an editor NoNot advertised
Read handwriting No“Challenging at this point in time”
Runs on iPhone, iPadiOS, Android, web

Three rows go against us: transposition, the song gallery and platforms. If you need any of those, the rest of the table does not matter much.

Which one should you choose?

Get Halbestunde for Android or a browser, regular transposing, a lifetime purchase or a song gallery. Get Sheetly on iPhone or iPad if the point of the scan is to learn the piece: hear it, loop the hard bars, record a take, and ask a coach that has read the notes about bar 12.

  • Android phone, or you want it on a laptop. Halbestunde. Sheetly is on iPhone and iPad only.
  • You need the piece in a different key. Halbestunde.
  • You want to open the app and play something today, without a page in front of you. Halbestunde, for the gallery.
  • You want to know what an accuracy number actually means before you trust it. Sheetly, because the method and test set are published.
  • You are stuck on a bar and want to ask why. Sheetly. Its coach answers about your bar.

Questions

Halbestunde vs PlayScore 2 vs Sheetly: which sheet music scanner app is best?

The best sheet music scanner app depends on your phone and on what you want after the scan. On Android, choose PlayScore 2 or Halbestunde, because Sheetly is on iPhone and iPad only. Best for offline use or instant on-device scanning: PlayScore 2. Best for the web, transposition, a song gallery or a lifetime purchase: Halbestunde. Best on iPhone or iPad when you want to practise the page: Sheetly, because the AI coach has read the actual notes of the page you photographed, and the bar you loop, slow down and record is the bar you can ask the coach about. We know of no published head-to-head accuracy test of the three apps.

Can Sheetly or Halbestunde read handwritten sheet music?

Sheetly does not read handwriting, and Halbestunde’s own materials describe reading it as “challenging at this point in time”.

Can you correct a misread note in Sheetly or Halbestunde?

Sheetly has no correction editor, and we could not find one advertised for Halbestunde. In Sheetly, the fix for a misread note is a better photograph and a rescan.

Does Halbestunde run on Android?

Yes. Halbestunde runs on iOS, Android and the web. Sheetly runs on iPhone and iPad as a Forte subscription.