Simply Piano Alternative: An App for the Sheet Music You Already Have
Looking for a Simply Piano alternative? In this guide, we compare Simply Piano and Sheetly side by side, explain what each app is built to do, and help you choose the one that fits the printed music on your stand.
Simply Piano is a lesson app with its own songs and its own course, and it listens through the microphone to tell you whether you hit the right note. If you are starting from zero without a teacher, that structure can be exactly what gets you going.
But a lot of piano players are not starting from zero. You might have a teacher, a method book and a stack of printed pieces. You might be working through an exam syllabus, or playing from a hymnal. That music is already chosen for you, and it is not in any app's song library. What you need then is an app that reads your music, not one that replaces it.
Sheetly is built for that player. You photograph your printed page, Sheetly plays it back, and its coach has read the notes. Below, we look at what each app does well, including where Simply Piano is the better choice.
- Keep Simply Piano if you are learning from zero without a teacher and want a structured course that hears you play and tells you whether you hit the note.
- Try Sheetly if the music you practice is printed: a method book, pieces from a teacher, an exam syllabus, a hymnal. Sheetly reads that page and plays it.
- Sheetly is, as far as we know, the only sheet-music app where you photograph your own printed page and then ask an AI coach about that score by bar number. It does not listen to you play or replace a teacher.
A note on who wrote this: we make Sheetly. We have not measured Simply Piano and make no claims about it beyond what its own materials describe. Where Simply Piano is the better tool, we say so.
What Simply Piano is built to do
Simply Piano teaches piano from its own library of songs and exercises. While you play, it listens through the microphone and checks whether you played the right notes. That is its whole design: because it controls the content, it knows every note in advance and can judge what it hears. It does not scan the printed music you already own, and its feedback is about your playing, not about the notation.
For a beginner with no teacher, that loop of playing, being heard and being corrected is genuinely useful, and Sheetly does not do it. If what you value most is an app telling you that the F sharp you played was actually an F, keep Simply Piano. Flowkey and Yousician work the same way, so they are worth a look too.
The fit starts to slip once you outgrow the song library and your music comes from somewhere else: a teacher's book, an exam syllabus, a choir's photocopy. None of that is in a lesson app's library, and the app has no camera path to get it there.
Simply Piano and Sheetly side by side
The short version: Simply Piano listens to you play its own songs and corrects you. Sheetly reads your printed page, plays it, and has a coach that has read it. In a way, the two apps are almost mirror images of each other.
| Sheetly | Simply Piano | |
|---|---|---|
| Reads your printed page into playable notes | Yes: photograph or PDF, server-side recognition | No: teaches from its own song library |
| Plays the score back | Yes, any tempo, loop a bar or passage, piano and other sounds | Plays its own lesson content |
| Listens to you play | No | Yes: checks notes through the microphone |
| AI coach about your score | Yes, has read the notes; answers by bar number | Feedback is about your playing, not a chat about the notation |
| Library and PDF reading | Your own scanned and imported scores | Its own song library |
| Platform | iPhone and iPad | See its own materials |
How Sheetly works with your own page
You photograph a printed page or import a PDF. Sheetly reads the engraved notation on a server and gives you back a score that plays. From there you can set any tempo, loop one bar or a whole passage, choose piano, organ, flute, trumpet or another sound, record your take, and export the score as PDF, MIDI or MusicXML.
The coach has read the notes on your page, so you can ask about it by bar number. Say your teacher gave you a new piece and you ask how to finger bars 5 to 8. The coach answers from the score: those bars sit under one hand position if you start bar 5 with your thumb on C, and the only stretch is the sixth in bar 7. Ask what to practice before Thursday and it points you to bars 5 to 8 hands separately at 60, then the left hand alone in bars 9 to 12 where the pattern changes. It does not hear you play. Your teacher does that.

How well Sheetly reads a page is measured, not guessed. On our 31-piece benchmark, strict F1 (pitch, onset and duration all correct) was 97.37% on clean renders and 97.34% on simulated phone photographs. On the public OLiMPiC suite of 60 systems cut from real scanned pages, Sheetly scored 92.3% on average, with usable output for all 60. The full method is on the benchmark page. Lesson apps and closed products were not part of it.
What Sheetly does not do
Sheetly does not listen to you play or mark your notes right or wrong. It reads printed, engraved notation only, so not handwriting, guitar tab or shape notes. There is no editor for fixing a note by hand: if a note is misread, a better photograph and a rescan is the fix. Scanning and the coach need an internet connection, but scanned scores play back offline.
Which one should you choose?
Keep Simply Piano if you are learning without a teacher and want a course that listens to you and corrects the notes. Use Sheetly if your music is printed and you want to hear it, loop the hard bars, record a take and ask the coach what is written in bar 12.
- Complete beginner, no teacher, no music of your own. Simply Piano, or a similar lesson app.
- You want the app to hear you and mark your notes. Simply Piano.
- You have a teacher and a book. Sheetly. The page is already chosen; you need to hear it and practice it.
- Exam pieces, choir parts, photocopies. Sheetly.
- You want to ask what to drill tonight in this piece. Sheetly.
Plenty of players use both: a lesson app to get started, and Sheetly once the music on the stand comes from a teacher, a book or an exam list.
Questions
Can a beginner use Sheetly?
Yes, if the beginner has printed music to work from: a method book, a teacher's pieces, a hymnal. Sheetly runs on iPhone and iPad as a Forte subscription.
Does Sheetly listen to me play like Simply Piano does?
No. Sheetly plays your page back to you and lets you record yourself so you can listen afterwards, but it does not hear you live or mark notes right or wrong.
Can Sheetly play songs I do not have the sheet music for?
No. Sheetly has no song library. It plays the printed music you photograph or import as a PDF.