Sheetly vs ScanScore: A MusicXML File or a Piece You Can Play?
Not sure whether you need Sheetly or ScanScore? In this guide, we compare a desktop editor that gives you a corrected MusicXML file with a phone app that turns a photograph into something you can practise, and help you pick by the ending you want.
ScanScore is desktop software for turning a printed score into a clean digital file. You scan the page, correct the mistakes by hand, and export a MusicXML file to your notation program. If you arrange, engrave or prepare parts, that corrected file is exactly what you are after.
Sheetly is a phone app with a different goal. You photograph a page and practise it: play it, loop it, slow it down, record yourself and ask a coach about it. The scan is not the end product. The piece you can play is.
So the most useful question is what you want to be holding at the end: a file, or a piece you can play. Below, we compare the two honestly, starting with where ScanScore is the better tool.
- Pick ScanScore if you want an editable, corrected MusicXML file at the end and are happy to sit at a desktop for it.
- Pick Sheetly if you want to hear and practise the piece on your phone, from a photograph.
- ScanScore has a correction editor and works offline. Sheetly has no editor and needs a connection to scan.
A note on who wrote this: we make Sheetly, so read this as a comparison by someone with a horse in the race. We state our method, publish numbers only where we have measured, and say plainly where the other product is better.
Where ScanScore is the better choice
ScanScore’s editor shows you what the recognition got wrong and lets you fix it in place before you export to MusicXML. It works offline on a desktop, and its tiers let you pay for exactly as many staves as your music has. Sheetly has none of that.
The correction editor
Every optical music recognition system makes mistakes. In ScanScore you see the result next to the original page and fix a wrong note or a missed accidental with a click. No phone app offers that workflow, including ours. When every note of a rehearsal part has to be right, repairing five mistakes instead of rescanning is a real advantage.
A proper export pipeline
ScanScore exists to feed notation software. For the cleanest MusicXML into MuseScore, Sibelius, Dorico or Finale, a desktop tool with an editor in the loop is the right shape. The trial limits MusicXML export to a few measures, so plan your evaluation around that.
Offline, on a desktop
ScanScore runs locally, so there is no upload, no connection and no waiting on a server. Sheetly needs a connection to scan a new page and to ask the coach, because the recognition runs on our servers. Scores you have already scanned play back offline.
Paying for what you need
ScanScore is paid, with tiers by the number of staves it will read, so a flute player and a choral arranger are not paying for the same thing. Sheetly is a single Forte subscription.
Where Sheetly is the better choice
Sheetly starts from a phone photograph instead of a flatbed scan. It plays the page back on your iPhone or iPad, loops a bar, slows the tempo, records your own take, and has a coach that has read the notes of the piece.
It starts from a photograph
Most people do not own a flatbed scanner, and most sheet music is in a bound book on a music stand. Sheetly’s recognition is designed for the perspective, shadow and page curl of a photograph taken with the phone you already have. ScanScore has a companion phone app, but it is built around flat scans that you correct on a computer.
On our 31-piece benchmark, Sheetly scored 97.34% strict F1 on simulated phone photographs and 97.37% on clean renders. Strict F1 means a note only counts when its pitch, timing and length are all right. The photograph number is where a design built around the camera shows.
We publish numbers only against systems anyone can run head-to-head on the same pages, such as the open-source Audiveris, and we have not measured ScanScore. Here is the method.
It is a practice player, not a file
Once the page is read, Sheetly gives you a play button at any tempo, a loop on exactly the bars that keep falling apart, a choice of piano, organ, flute, trumpet and more, and a recorder so you can hear your own take against the score.

ScanScore also plays a scan back and changes the tempo, but it is an editing and export tool that hands you a file. Both are correct outcomes, just different ones.
The coach
Sheetly includes a coach that has read the actual notes of the piece you scanned, so you can ask why bar 12 keeps falling apart and get an answer about what is written in your bar 12.
It might tell you, for example, that bar 12 is where the left hand crosses over, that you are probably re-taking the thumb, and that a 2–1–3 fingering with the wrist moving right through the bar will help. Ask what to drill tonight and it might suggest bars 12 to 15, hands separately, at 60.
It still exports
If you do want the file, Sheetly exports PDF, MIDI and MusicXML, but without the step of correcting the transcription by hand: the file is the recognition result as read. If a scan comes back with an error, your fix is a better photograph and a rescan rather than an edit.
ScanScore and Sheetly, feature by feature
This table comes from each product’s own feature list. Products change, so check the current version before you buy.
| After the scan, can you… | Sheetly | ScanScore |
|---|---|---|
| Hear it played back | Yes | Yes |
| Change the tempo | Yes | Yes |
| Loop one difficult bar | Yes | Not advertised |
| Record your own take against it | Yes | Not advertised |
| Ask questions about your score | Yes | No |
| Export MusicXML / MIDI | Yes | Yes |
| Correct mistakes in an editor | No | Yes |
| Work with no internet | No | Yes |
| Start from a phone photograph | Yes | Companion phone app |
| Runs on | iPhone, iPad | Desktop, with a companion app |
The editor row and the offline row are two things ScanScore does that we do not. If either is essential to you, the rest of the table does not matter much.
Which one should you choose?
Get ScanScore for a corrected MusicXML file, on a desktop with, ideally, a flatbed scanner. Get Sheetly to photograph a page and practise it: hear it, loop it, slow it down, record yourself and ask about it.
- You arrange, engrave or teach from notation software. ScanScore. The editor is the product.
- Your music is in bound books on a stand. Sheetly. It is built for the photograph.
- Every note must be perfect before you use it. ScanScore, because you can fix the mistakes yourself.
- You want to hear the piece tonight and drill the hard bars. Sheetly.
- You need both. They do not compete for the same slot: use a desktop tool to produce parts and a phone app to practise them.
Questions
What is MusicXML?
MusicXML is a file format for written music that notation programs such as MuseScore, Sibelius, Dorico and Finale can import. ScanScore and Sheetly both export it.
Can I fix a misread note in Sheetly?
No. Sheetly has no correction editor, so the fix is a better photograph and a rescan. If you need to correct notes by hand, ScanScore’s editor is built for that.
Does ScanScore work offline?
Yes, ScanScore runs locally on a desktop. Sheetly needs a connection to scan a new page and to ask the coach, but scores you have already scanned play back offline.