Sheetly vs PhotoScore: A Practice App or a Professional Scanner?

Wondering whether you need Sheetly or PhotoScore? In this guide, we explain why the engraver's scanner and the learner's scanner are two different kinds of tool, and help you pick the one that fits what you do with your music.

An open book of printed piano music in warm light

PhotoScore & NotateMe is the long-standing professional option for scanning music. It is desktop software tied to Sibelius, built around a real scanner and a mature correction workflow. If you arrange, engrave or prepare parts for other musicians, it is the tool engravers have relied on for years.

Sheetly is built for someone else: the player. It is a phone app where you photograph a page, hear it, loop it, slow it down, record a take and ask a coach about it. Many people who search for a sheet music scanner find PhotoScore first, when what they actually want is to hear and practise a piece.

Below, we set the two side by side. Knowing which kind of tool you are shopping for saves money in one direction and frustration in the other.

  • Pick PhotoScore if you produce performance materials by arranging, engraving or preparing parts, especially in Sibelius, and you need to correct the result note by note.
  • Pick Sheetly if you are learning or teaching a piece and want a page from a bound book playing on your phone within a minute, with the tools to practise it.
  • PhotoScore has a correction editor and works offline on a desktop. Sheetly has neither. Sheetly has looping, take recording and a coach, and PhotoScore does not advertise any of them.

A note on who wrote this: we make Sheetly, so read this as a comparison by someone with a horse in the race. We state our method, publish numbers only where we have measured, and say plainly where the other product is better.

Where PhotoScore is the better choice

PhotoScore has been the scanner engravers rely on for years. It has a mature correction editor, it ties into Sibelius, it is designed around a flatbed scanner rather than a phone camera, and it handles the engraving workflow from start to finish. A professional preparing parts for an ensemble should not switch to a phone app.

The professional workflow

PhotoScore takes a scanned page and recognises not just the notes but the engraving detail professionals need. It lets you correct what it missed, then hands a finished result to a notation program. If a whole section will read from your printed part, that care is the whole job, and a phone app built for quick playback is the wrong tool.

Sibelius

If you live in Sibelius, PhotoScore is its natural companion, with years of integration behind it.

A real scanner, offline

PhotoScore expects a desktop and a scanner, and it works offline. A flatbed scan is flat, evenly lit and square-on. That will always be an easier page to read than a phone photograph of a curled page in a bound book.

NotateMe reads handwriting

PhotoScore’s companion, NotateMe, reads handwritten music. Sheetly reads printed, engraved notation only. If your manuscripts are handwritten, that is a real gap in what Sheetly can do, not a difference of taste.

Where Sheetly is the better choice

Sheetly is for a player who wants to hear and practise a piece, not publish it: the adult beginner, the returning player, the student or the teacher who searched for a sheet music scanner and found PhotoScore first. It starts from a phone photograph and is built around tempo, bar looping, take recording and a coach that has read the score.

The phone in your pocket

There is no scanner, no desktop and no setup. You hold the phone over the page on the music stand, and a minute later it plays.

Sheetly on an iPhone, photographing a printed page of music
No scanner needed: photograph the page on the stand.

On our 31-piece benchmark, Sheetly scored 97.34% strict F1 on simulated phone photographs and 97.37% on clean renders. Strict F1 means a note only counts when its pitch, timing and length are all right. When your input is a camera, the photograph number is the one that matters.

SheetlyAudiveris, the best free scanner
97%
88%
Clean scans
97%
50%
Phone photos
92%
58%
Real scans
Strict scoring on identical pages, October 2026. A note counts only if pitch, timing and length are right. Inputs, raw transcriptions and the scorer are published, so one command reproduces this chart. The benchmark, and how to check it

We publish strict F1 only against systems anyone can run head-to-head on the same pages, such as the open-source Audiveris. We have not run PhotoScore through that test, so we make no claim about how it would score. Here is the method.

Built for practice, not for print

After the scan, you get a player designed for learning: any tempo, a loop on the bars you cannot play yet, a choice of sounds, and a recorder so you can hear your own take against the score. PhotoScore also plays a scan back and changes the tempo, but it is built for engraving and export rather than practice.

The coach

Sheetly includes a coach that has read the actual notes of the piece you scanned. Ask which four bars to drill tonight, what fingering the left hand should use in bar 12, or why a passage keeps falling apart, and the answer refers to what is written on your page.

For example, ask “bar 12 keeps falling apart, what am I doing wrong?” and it might tell you that bar 12 is where the left hand crosses over, that you are probably re-taking the thumb, and that a 2–1–3 fingering with the wrist moving through the bar will help. Ask what to drill tonight and it might suggest bars 12 to 15, hands separately, at 60.

Cost

PhotoScore is paid software, priced for professionals, and the full version is not cheap. Sheetly is a Forte subscription on iPhone and iPad. If you only want to hear one piece from one book, a professional engraving tool is a lot to pay for.

It still exports

Sheetly exports PDF, MIDI and MusicXML, which Sibelius imports, so a scan can still end up in notation software. What you will not get is PhotoScore’s direct integration or its correction editor: the MusicXML is the recognition result as read. For a learner that is rarely a problem. For an engraver it is everything.

PhotoScore and Sheetly, feature by feature

This table comes from each product’s own feature list. Products change, so check the current version before you buy.

Compiled from each product’s own published feature list, August 2026. “Not advertised” means we could not find the feature documented, not that it is definitely absent.
After the scan, can you… SheetlyPhotoScore
Hear it played back YesYes
Change the tempo YesYes
Loop one difficult bar YesNot advertised
Record your own take against it YesNot advertised
Ask questions about your score YesNo
Export MusicXML / MIDI YesYes
Correct mistakes in an editor NoYes
Read handwritten music NoYes, via NotateMe
Work with no internet NoYes
Runs on iPhone, iPadDesktop, with mobile versions

Three rows go to PhotoScore, and they are not small ones: the editor, handwriting and offline use. If your work needs any of them, PhotoScore is the right kind of tool, and this page should not talk you out of it.

Which one should you choose?

Get PhotoScore if you produce music for other people to read, by arranging, engraving or preparing parts, especially in Sibelius. Get Sheetly if you are learning or teaching a piece and want a photographed page playing on your phone, with a loop, a tempo control, a recorder and a coach.

  • Professional engraver or arranger. PhotoScore. This is its home ground.
  • Handwritten manuscripts. PhotoScore with NotateMe. Sheetly does not read handwriting.
  • Adult beginner, returning player or student. Sheetly. Hear the page, then practise it.
  • Teacher who wants a piece demonstrated at a tempo a student can follow. Sheetly, for the tempo and loop controls.
  • You want a file in notation software and do not need to correct it first. Both export MusicXML. Sheetly is a quick way to find out whether the scan is good enough.

Questions

Does PhotoScore run on a phone?

PhotoScore is desktop software with mobile versions, built around a flatbed scanner. Sheetly runs only on iPhone and iPad and starts from a phone photograph.

Can Sheetly read handwritten music like NotateMe?

No. Sheetly reads printed, engraved notation only. For handwritten manuscripts, PhotoScore’s companion NotateMe is the tool to look at.

Can I open a Sheetly scan in Sibelius?

Yes. Sheetly exports MusicXML, which Sibelius imports. The file is the recognition result as read, because Sheetly has no correction editor.